Candy branching process

The mathematical puzzle in the latest weekend edition of Le Monde is as follows:

Two kids are given three boxes of chocolates with a total of 32 pieces. Rather than sharing evenly, they play the following game: Each in turn, they pick one of the three boxes, empty its contents in a jar and pick some chocolates from one of the remaining boxes so that no box stays empty. The game ends with the current player’s loss when this is no longer possible. What is the optimal strategy?

This led me to consider a simple branching process starting from a multinomial

(u_1,v_1,w_1)\sim \mathcal{M}_3(29;1/3,1/3,1/3)

to define (x_1=1+u_1,y_1=1+v_1,z_1=1+w_1). and then following the above splitting process, namely the selection of the dead and of the split components, x_t and y_t>1 say, and the generation of

(u_{t+1},v_{t+1})\sim \mathcal{M}_2(y_t-2;1/2,1/2)

with the updated value being

(x_{t+1},y_{t+1},z_{t+1}) = (1+u_{t+1},1+v_{t+1},z_t).

This process is obviously not optimal but on the opposite completely random. Running a short R program like

N=32
prc=story=rep(1,3)+as.vector(rmultinom(1,(N-3),prob=rep(1,3)))
while (sum(prc)>3){
  if (sum(prc>1)==1)
         i=(1:3)[prc>1]           #split
   else
         i=sample((1:3)[prc>1],1) #split
   j=sample((1:3)[-i],1)          #unchanged
   prc=c(prc[j],1+as.vector(rmultinom(1,prc[i]-2,prob=rep(1,2))))
   story=rbind(story,prc)
}

leads to a histogram of the game duration which is as follows. (Note that the R command sample((1:3)[prc>1]) does not produce what it should when only one term of prc is different from 1, hence the condition.) Obviously, this is not a very interesting branching process in that the sequence always ends up in a few steps…

Of course, this does not tell much about the initial puzzle. However, discussing the problem with Antoine Dreyer and Robin Ryder led to Antoine obtaining all winning and loosing configurations up to N=32 by a recursive R algorithm and to Robin establishing a complete resolution (I do not want to unveil it before he does!) that involves the funny facts [a] any starting configuration with only odd numbers is loosing and [b] any N that is a power of 2, like 32, always produces winning configurations.

One Response to “Candy branching process”

  1. [...] branching process By robinryder Christian Robert has basically forced me to post my solution to last week’s Le Monde [...]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 669 other followers