The Night Angel Trilogy

“There was no thesis, counterpointed with antithesis, harmonized into synthesis. It wasn’t that kind of music. The music of logic was too patrician for the streets, too subtle, the nuances all wrong.” Brent Weeks, Shadow’s Edge

I have finished the Night Angel Trilogy quite a while ago but felt so far little inclination to comment on it as I was quite disappointed by the series. The third volume, Beyond the Shadows, is quite unappealing and at some point it turns into such a bleak story of rape and slaughter that I was close to give up on the book. (This is when one of the main and so far “good” characters turns into a mad homicidal and sadistic Godking. Maybe a necessary part of the plot but unpleasant nonetheless, especially because Weeks makes it sound so reasonable…)

“You realize it might make a quantitative rather than qualitative difference?” “Huh?” Brent Weeks, Beyond the Shadows

As posted earlier, I did like the first volume The Way of Shadows as it truly made for a compelling and unusual read. But the characters do not evolve nor take much depth in the subsequent volumes, Shadow’s Edge and Beyond the Shadows (except for the female assassin Vi who alas often acts as a lovelorn teenager…) The interesting parallel structure of the thief society all but disappears once the new king comes to power, the influential (Aes Sedai or Bene Gesserit like) sisterhood is almost invisible and thus hardly influential. The fight for survival of the (future) king Logan in the dungeon filled with psychopaths is a better-written part, but the psychopaths turn up being a wee too nice to be credible! The central character Elene who was creating the (rather predictable) tension about the antagonistic inclinations of the other central character Kylar, torn between a prospect for family life and a magical assassin’s career, mostly drops from the last volume, Beyond the Shadows, only to reappear at the end to save the day. While the disappearance of major characters is a good novelist’s trick to keep the pace going and the reader hooked, I find the slaughter of many main characters overdone.  At last, the crudity and cruelty of the story, which were innovative in the first volume, end up wearing up in the following ones. Unless you specialise into gory fantasy (!), I would thus not recommend the Night Angel Trilogy. (There is an interview of Brent Weeks by Patrick Rothfuss that does not bring much about the books… Patrick Rothfuss should better be working on the sequel of The Name of the Wind I am desperate for! I also just found Linus Torvald, yes THE Linus Torvald!, recommended the trilogy two years ago…)

2 Responses to “The Night Angel Trilogy”

  1. […] and not much time to introspection nor subtlety. Far from the creativity of Brent Weeks and his Night Angel trilogy for instance. Nonetheless, it makes for a very enjoyable, uncomplicated, quick read and I am […]

  2. […] writer, and I do not see the point in debating about supernatural beings (except when reviewing a fantasy book!). However, the arguments of Moix are rather limited from a philosophical […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: