Lacking skills

I received this question from Luke Bornn to answer for a new Q&A entry in the ISBA Bulletin:

“From your experience, what skill do you think is most often lacking in today’s statistics Ph.D. graduates?  What steps can a current graduate student undertake to remedy this deficiency?”

First, let me stress that I restrict my answer to French Ph.D. graduates and warn the reader that the environment for Ph.D. students in French institutions strongly differs from the ones in UK or US universities. Even though our students have a proper five-year training in maths, probability and statistics (plus possibly additional fields like economics, computer science, engineering, sociology, or, more rarely, biology, astronomy, ecology), there is not the same progressive integration of graduate students within the research faculty body as the one we see in the UK or the US. Ph.D. students remain students till the end of their thesis and often beyond. This is of course a terrible situation that we are trying to alleviate at our individual level, when the conditions allow as in CREST.

Due to this partial isolation from more senior researchers, our Ph.D. students often lack both the ability to engage in collaborative works and to conduct separate projects in parallel. This puts them at a clear disadvantage when starting as assistant professors since they need to catch up at this level as well as prepare (a lot of) new courses. The solution is to get them to interact with senior researchers as early as possible during seminars, lectures and meetings. Once again, this evaluation is fairly special to the local conditions. As Julien commented, this reflects more on the faculty than on the Ph.D. graduates…

Else, and to answer more precisely the Bulletin question, I consider the difficulty in writing papers a common occurrence among our Ph.D. students. It often is a gruelling process for them to have a paper completed at a level such that it can be considered for publication. To me, this is much more an issue than lacking proper bases in probability or in a field of specialisation/application. The remedy is to work on writing skills from the start of the thesis, or even before, trying to write short pieces evaluated by peers and faculty. In addition, refereeing papers as early in the thesis as possible helps a lot by providing examples as well as counterexamples. One of my colleagues at CREST had once a weekly refereeing seminar running around the papers submitted to the major econometrics journal he was editing. (Thanks to Julien and Pierre for comments, not necessarily included in this post!)

3 Responses to “Lacking skills”

  1. […] for the previous ISBA Bulletin, Luke Bornn sent me this (impossible!) question, to be answered in a few hundred words. First, let […]

  2. […] recently posted on his blog about about the lack of writing skills in statistics PhD students in France. Certainly the same issue is true here in the U.S. Since I am only a second year assistant […]

  3. ce que tu dis sur les talents d’ecriture de nos chers thesards est effectivement vrai… apres, il y a une telle pression sur le besoin de publier pour trouver un poste que si on les aide pas un peu/beaucoup sur les premiers travaux, cela va leur faire perdre un temps trop important par rapport a la publication et les handicapera par rapport aux candidatures!
    je suis donc souvent tres embete… j’ai tendance a leur faire faire un premier jet et reprendre le tout (parfois from scratch) en leur laissant des parties… ce n’est pas du tout optimal j’en conviens…
    Concernant leurs difficultes a collaborer avec l’exterieur… la aussi je ne suis pas tout a fait d’accord… pendant leur these ils doivent faire preuve “eux-memes” d’originalite et de qualite mathematique et donc un travail personnel… auquel doit s’ajouter en fin de these des collaborations exterieures… mais la tu oublies que tout le monde n’est pas a paris avec beaucoup de rencontres/ de collaborateurs potentiels avec plus d’argent pour voyager… si tu es en Province, petit labo sans trop d’argent, il sera bcp plus dur de pouvoir trouver des collaborateurs exterieurs…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.