Archive for sum of uniforms

another riddle

Posted in Books, Kids, R with tags , , , , , , on March 29, 2016 by xi'an

A very nice puzzle on The Riddler last week that kept me busy on train and plane rides, runs and even in between over the weekend. The core of the puzzle is about finding the optimal procedure to select k guesses about the value of a uniformly random integer x in {a,a+1,…,b}, given that each guess y produces the position of x respective to y (less, equal, or more). If y=x at one stage, the player wins x. Optimal being defined as maximising the expected gain. After some (and more) experimentation, I found that, when b-a is large enough [depending on k], the optimal guess at stage i is b-f(i) with f(k)=0 and f(i-1)=2f(i)+1. For the values given on The Riddler, a=1,b=1000,k=9, my solution is to first guess at y=1000-f(9)=255 and this produces a gain of 380.31 with a probability of winning of 0.510, which seems amazingly large, but not so much when considering that 2⁹ is close to 500. Continue reading