WoT first three impressions

As I was pessimistic about the adaptation of the behemoth (14 volumes) Wheel of Time adaptation as an Amazon TV series, I was not particularly disappointed after watching the first three episodes! Regarding the following comments, I do realise that having started reading these books in 1990 and having completed reading the 15 volumes puts me in a tiny minority and that anyone unfamiliar with Jordan’s universe would take the story as it comes rather than checking for discrepancies from the gospel.

Good stuff:

  • Egwene and Nynaeve are delivering strong personalities to their respective character, kudos!, in a sense improving upon their book counterparts!
  • Moraine Sedai is reasonably well rendered, although she could have appeared as more ambiguous though (and why did they add this injury in the Bel Tine scene to the original story?)
  • this includes her telling of the story of Manethren
  • the way Trollocs and Fades are rendered is great
  • the scenery is mostly fabulous, esp. the entrance to Shadar Logoth
  • meeting the Tuatha’an was great, except for the fake scare at the beginning, and the arguing about their non-violent commitment is pretty convincing
  • the idea making the first Darkfriend we meet  more humane and ambivalent than in the book is hopefully going to be seen again

Bad lines:

  • the choice of having the Dragon being one of the five friends, incl. Egwene and Nynaeve, clashes with the structure of Jordan’s world, as well as Moraine’s early infodump
  • Matt, Perrin, and Rand appear incredibly naïve, but maybe this was already the case in the book
  • Matt is decidedly downright unpleasant from the start (i.e., even before Shadar Logoth)
  • the notion to have Perrin already married and the ensuing trauma are terrible novelties, the more because he doesn’t look so traumatized by the ending
  • the special treatment of Nynaeve by one trolloc is missing from the book and unclear as to its contribution to the plot (and why would Moraine leave without her?)
  • costumes are terrible, almost uniformly!, and too modern, looking like they were bought from second hand stores (and more globally there is a feeling of cheapness in the set designs, from Shadar Logoth to Tar Valon)
  • Moraine’s and Lan’s fight in the Two Rivers is rather unconvincing and messy (why did she need to turn this nice inn building into missiles?!)
  • why would Rand and Tam miss the village Bel Tine celebration to return to their farm?
  • The Guardian got highly negative about the show and even about the books (which the first reviewer had never read) maybe seeing too much in the (admittedly terribly heavy) writing style of Robert Jordan and maybe trying too had to draw a comparison with Game of Thrones (just like so many critics). So did the New York Times
  • making the only Darkfriend so far coming out of the open and a sword expert
  • Lan not commenting on Rand’s father’s heron sword, while zooming on said heron several times
  • the sooo slooow walk of Egwene and Perrin in the third episode once they get on track(s), thanks to the wolves
  • the Whitecloacks being depicted as just too evil from the start, with no ambivalence whatsoever (this was also true in the book, which [spoiler alert!] makes Galad joining them later—sorry for the spoiler—difficult to fathom)
  • similarly, the first Red Sister we meet (Liandrin) is similarly too one-sided to give a balanced picture of the different Ajahs in the White Tower

4 Responses to “WoT first three impressions”

  1. Arnaud Guillin Says:

    I would not be as negative as you… In the book, Rand&al were really naive… Moiraine has not insisted they could be Taveren… and they have included the girls to be more of the now generation (as well as moiriane and siuan being together…)…The magic is well depicted… you begin to see differences of ajah in the camps and Liandrin was always quite bad… They have also skipped the encounter with Morgase and Elayne which was in the first books if I remember well… and if I remember well, Mat did come with the other in The Ways… no?? I was also surprised that Lan did no remarks on Rand’s sword which is crucial… so for me, it is more the differences in the story that may be crucial in the following… I like watching this show (even if it is not the best one) but as you say 14 books… to do in what 5-6 seasons…

    • Negative is my middle name! The last show was somewhat better with at last Min appearing in the story. And Padan Fain reappearing. A tiny little bit. The prologue was great, but reveals Rand’s lineage much earlier than in the books. May you always find water and shade in 2022!

    • I just found out that Matt not joining the others was unintended and due to Barney Harris, the actor playing Matt, leaving the show. A new actor will play Matt in Season 2.

      • ok for the explanation… too bad, I like the actor… Padan fain makes the tiniest apparition possible.. it goes quite fast between Lan and Nynaeve also..

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.