Archive for Le Monde

Le Monde puzzle [#1099]

Posted in Books, Kids, R with tags , , , , , on April 28, 2019 by xi'an

A simple 2×2 Le Monde mathematical puzzle:

Arielle and Brandwein play a game out of two distinct even integers between 1500 and 2500,  and y. Providing one another with either the pair (x/2,y+x/2) or the pair (x+y/2,y/2) until they run out of even possibilities or exceed 6 rounds. When x=2304, what is the value of y that makes Brandwein win?

Which I solved by a recursive function (under the constraint of a maximum of 11 levels of recursion):

nezt=function(x,y,i=1){
  if ((i>11)||((is.odd(x)&is.odd(y)))){ return(-1)
  }else{
    z=-1
    if (is.even(x)) z=-nezt(x/2,y+x/2,i+1)
    if (is.even(y)) z=max(z,-nezt(y/2,x+y/2,i+1))
    return(z)}}

and checking all values of y between 1500 and 2500 when x=2304, which produces y=1792 as the only value when Arielle loses. The reason behind (?) is that both 2304 and 1792 are divisible by 2⁸, which means no strategy avoids reaching stalemate after 8 steps, when it is Arielle’s turn to play.

the Montréal declarAIon

Posted in University life with tags , , , , , , , , , , , , on April 27, 2019 by xi'an

In conjunction with Yoshua Bengio being one of the three recipients of the 2018 Alan Turing award, Nature ran an interview of him about the Montréal Déclaration for a responsible AI, which he launched at NeurIPS last December.

“Self-regulation is not going to work. Do you think that voluntary taxation works? It doesn’t.”

Reflecting on the dangers of abuse of and by AIs, from surveillance, to discrimination, but being somewhat unclear on the means to implement the ten generic principles listed there. (I had missed the Declaration when it came up.) I agree with the principles stressed by this list, well-being, autonomy, privacy, democracy, diversity, prudence, responsability, and sustainability, it remains to be seem how they can be imposed upon corporations whose own public image puts more restraint on them than ethics or on governments that are all too ready to automatise justice, police, and the restriction of citizen’s rights. Which makes the construction of a responsible AI institution difficult to imagine, if the current lack of outreach of the extra-national institutions is the gauge. (A striking coincidence is that, when  Yoshua Bengio pointed out that France was trying to make Europe an AI power, there was also a tribune in Le Monde about the lack of practical impact of this call to arms, apart from more academics moving to half-time positions in private companies.) [Warning: the picture does not work well with the dark background theme of this blog.]

Le Monde puzzle [#1094]

Posted in Books, Kids, R with tags , , , , , , on April 23, 2019 by xi'an

A rather blah number Le Monde mathematical puzzle:

Find all integer multiples of 11111 with exactly one occurrence of each decimal digit..

Which I solved by brute force, by looking at the possible range of multiples (and  borrowing stringr:str_count from Robin!)

> combien=0
> for (i in 90001:900008){
  j=i*11111
  combien=combien+(min(stringr::str_count(j,paste(0:9)))==1)}
> combien
[1] 3456

And a bonus one:

Find all integers y that can write both as x³ and (10z)³+a with 1≤a≤999.

which does not offer much in terms of solutions since x³-v³=(x-v)(x²+xv+v²)=a shows that x² is less than 2a/3, meaning x is at most 25. Among such numbers only x=11,12 lead to a solution as x³=1331,1728.

Le Monde puzzle [#1092]

Posted in Statistics with tags , , , , , , , on April 18, 2019 by xi'an

A Latin square Le Monde mathematical puzzle that I found rather dreary:

A hidden 3×3 board contains all numbers from 1 to 9. Anselm wants to guess the board and makes two proposals. Berenicke tells him how many entries are in the right rows and colums for each proposal, along with the information that no entry is at the right location. Anselm deduces the right board.

Which I solved by brute force and not even simulated annealing, first defining a target

ordoku1=ordoku2=matrix(1,9,2)
ordoku1[,1]=c(1,1,1,2,2,2,3,3,3)
ordoku1[,2]=rep(1:3,3)
ordoku2[,1]=c(3,2,3,1,2,3,2,1,1)
ordoku2[,2]=c(2,2,3,2,3,1,1,3,1)
fitz=function(ordo){
  (sum(ordo[c(1,4,7),2]==1)==1)+(sum(ordo[c(2,5,8),2]==2)==1)+
  (sum(ordo[c(3,6,9),2]==3)==0)+(sum(ordo[c(1,2,3),1]==1)==1)+
  (sum(ordo[c(4,5,6),1]==2)==1)+(sum(ordo[c(7,8,9),1]==3)==2)+
  (sum(ordo[c(6,7,9),2]==1)==2)+(sum(ordo[c(1,2,4),2]==2)==1)+
  (sum(ordo[c(3,5,8),2]==3)==2)+(sum(ordo[c(4,8,9),1]==1)==1)+
  (sum(ordo[c(7,2,5),1]==2)==1)+(sum(ordo[c(1,3,6),1]==3)==0)+
  (!(0%in%apply((ordo-ordoku1)^2,1,sum)))+(!(0%in%apply((ordo-ordoku2)^2,1,sum)))
}

on a 9×9 board entry reproducing all items of information given by Berenicke. If all constraints are met, the function returns 14. And then searched for a solution at random:

temp=1
randw=function(ordo){
  for (t in 1:1e6){
    chlg=sample(1:9,2)
    temp=ordo[chlg[1],]
    ordo[chlg[1],]=ordo[chlg[2],]
    ordo[chlg[2],]=temp
    if (fitz(ordo)==14){
      print(ordo);break()}}}

which produces the correct board

4 3 5
6 7 1
9 2 8

Le Monde puzzle [#1088]

Posted in Books, Kids, R with tags , , , , , , , , on March 29, 2019 by xi'an

A board (Ising!) Le Monde mathematical puzzle in the optimisation mode, again:

On a 7×7 board, what is the maximal number of locations that one can occupy when imposing at least two empty neighbours ?

Which I tried to solve by brute force and simulated annealing (what else?!), first defining a target

targ=function(tabz){
  sum(tabz[-c(1,9),-c(1,9)]-1.2*(tabz[-c(1,9),-c(1,9)]*tabz[-c(8,9),-c(1,9)]
      +tabz[-c(1,9),-c(1,9)]*tabz[-c(1,2),-c(1,9)]
      +tabz[-c(1,9),-c(1,9)]*tabz[-c(1,9),-c(8,9)]
      +tabz[-c(1,9),-c(1,9)]*tabz[-c(1,9),-c(1,2)]>2))}

on a 9×9 board where I penalise prohibited configuration by a factor 1.2 (a wee bit more than empty nodes). The perimeter of the 9×9 board is filled with ones and never actualised. (In the above convoluted products, the goal is to count how many neighbours of the entries equal to one are also equal to one. More than 2 is penalised.) The simulated annealing move is then updating the 9×9 grid gridz:

temp=1
maxarg=curarg=targ(gridz)
for (t in 1:1e3){
  for (v in 1:1e4){
    i=sample(2:8,1);j=sample(2:8,1)
    newgrid=gridz;newgrid[i,j]=1-gridz[i,j]
    newarg=targ(newgrid)
    if (log(runif(1))<temp*(newarg-curarg)){
      gridz=newgrid;curarg=newarg}}
temp=temp+.01}

and calls to the procedure always return 28 entries as the optimum, as in

     [,1] [,2] [,3] [,4] [,5] [,6] [,7]
[1,]    1    0    1    0    1    0    1
[2,]    0    1    1    0    1    1    0
[3,]    1    1    0    1    0    1    1
[4,]    0    0    1    0    1    0    0
[5,]    1    1    0    1    0    1    1
[6,]    0    1    1    0    1    1    0
[7,]    1    0    1    0    1    0    1

As it happens, I had misread the wording of the original puzzle, which considered a dynamic placement of the units on the board, one at a time with two free neighbours imposed.

Le Monde puzzle [#1086]

Posted in pictures, Statistics, Travel with tags , , , , , , on March 7, 2019 by xi'an

A terse Le Monde mathematical puzzle in the optimisation mode:

What is the maximal fraction of the surface of a triangle occupied by an inner triangle ABC where Abigail picks a summit A on a first side, Berenice B on a second side, and then Abigails picks C on the third side, towards Abigail maximising and Berenice minimising this surface?

Which I first tried to solve by pen & paper, completing another black block for the occasion, as coding the brute force R version sounded too painful:

leading me to conclude that, for a rectangle triangle (although the result sounds independent of this feature), the optimum was the middle triangle, weighting one-fourth of the original surface. Reprogramming the question in the plane to Angkor produced the same output, modulo my approximation of the triangle continuum with a 200×200/2grid:

Le Monde puzzle [#1087]

Posted in Books, Kids, R, Statistics with tags , , , , , on February 25, 2019 by xi'an

A board-like Le Monde mathematical puzzle in the digit category:

Given a (k,m) binary matrix, what is the maximum number S of entries with only one neighbour equal to one? Solve for k=m=2,…,13, and k=6,m=8.

For instance, for k=m=2, the matrix

\begin{matrix} 0 &0\\ 1 &1\\ \end{matrix}

is producing the maximal number 4. I first attempted a brute force random filling of these matrices with only a few steps of explorations and got the numbers 4,8,16,34,44,57,… for the first cases. Since I was convinced that the square k² of a number k previously exhibited to reach its maximum as S=k² was again perfect in this regard, I then tried another approach based on Gibbs sampling and annealing (what else?):

gibzit=function(k,m,A=1e2,N=1e2){
  temp=1 #temperature
  board=sole=matrix(sample(c(0,1),(k+2)*(m+2),rep=TRUE),k+2,m+2)
  board[1,]=board[k+2,]=board[,1]=board[,m+2]=0 #boundaries
  maxol=counter(board,k,m) #how many one-neighbours?
  for (t in 1:A){#annealing
    for (r in 1:N){#basic gibbs steps
      for (i in 2:(k+1))
        for (j in 2:(m+1)){
          prop=board
          prop[i,j]=1-board[i,j]
          u=runif(1)
          if (log(u/(1-u))<temp*(counter(prop,k,m)-val)){ 
             board=prop;val=counter(prop,k,m) 
             if (val>maxol){
               maxol=val;sole=board}}
      }}
    temp=temp*2}
  return(sole[-c(1,k+2),-c(1,m+2)])}

which leads systematically to the optimal solution, namely a perfect square k² when k is even and a perfect but one k²-1 when k is odd. When k=6, m=8, all entries can afford one neighbour exactly,

> gibzbbgiz(6,8)
[1] 48
     [,1] [,2] [,3] [,4] [,5] [,6] [,7] [,8]
[1,]    1    0    0    1    1    0    0    1
[2,]    1    0    0    0    0    0    0    1
[3,]    0    0    1    0    0    1    0    0
[4,]    0    0    1    0    0    1    0    0
[5,]    1    0    0    0    0    0    0    1
[6,]    1    0    0    1    1    0    0    1

but this does not seem feasible when k=6, m=7, which only achieves 40 entries with one single neighbour.